Table of Contents
In this blog post, we’ll show you how to make your own cookie cutters using simple materials that you likely have at home. So, get ready to get creative and have some fun in the kitchen!

What are cookie cutters?
A cookie cutter is a small, hand-held tool used to cut cookies, brownies and other food items into desired shapes. A variety of shapes and sizes are available in metal, plastic, and silicone.
The Best Cookie Cutters to Use
These days, cookie cutters come in many different styles. But, what is the best type to use when you want to make perfectly shaped cookies every time?
One option is to use a metal cookie cutter. These tend to be very durable and can easily cut through dough. However, they can also be a little difficult to clean if you end up with dough stuck inside the cutter.
Another option is to use a silicone cookie cutter. Silicone is a soft material that makes it easy to cut through dough. And, since it’s flexible, it’s also easy to remove any cookies that may have been cut out. However, silicone can be a bit flimsy and may not be as durable as metal cookie cutters.
So, what is the best option? It really depends on your preferences. If you want a cutter that is durable and easy to clean, then metal is the way to go. But, if you are looking for something that is flexible and easy to use, then silicone may be the better option. Whichever type of cookie cutter you choose, just make sure that it is the right size for the cookies that you are trying to make.

Types of Plastic Making Cookie Cutters
In addition to the materials mentioned above, cookie cutters can also be made out of plastic. There are two types of plastic you can use: acrylic and polycarbonate.
Acrylic is a type of plastic that is often used to make signs and displays. It is durable, shatter-resistant, and easy to work with. However, it can also be quite expensive.
Polycarbonate is a type of plastic that is often used in safety glasses and motorcycle helmets. It is tough and shatter-resistant, making it a good choice for cookie cutters. However, it can be a bit more difficult to work with than acrylic.
Types of Metal Making Cookie Cutters
There are different types of metals used in making cookie cutters. They include aluminum, brass, copper and steel. Each metal has its own unique properties that make it a good choice for this kitchen tool.
Aluminum is a lightweight metal that is easy to work with. It is also corrosion-resistant, so it will stay looking new for longer.
Brass is a sturdy metal that can withstand a lot of wear and tear. It is also heat-resistant, making it a good choice for cookie cutters that will be used on the stovetop.
Copper is also heat-resistant and has a beautiful shine that makes it a popular choice for decorative cookie cutters. Steel is the strongest of the four metals mentioned here, making it a good choice for durable cookie cutters.
Which metal is right for you will depend on your needs and preferences. Try out a few different types to see which one you like best.
How To Make Cookie Cutters?
Make With Plastic
Making your own cookie cutters is a fun and easy project, and you can use them for all kinds of cookies, including sugar cookies, gingerbread cookies, and even Christmas cookies! You’ll need some supplies to get started:
- A sturdy piece of plastic
- A craft knife
- A pencil or pen
- Scissors
Step 1: Draw the shape of the cookie cutter you want on the plastic with the pencil or pen. Be sure to make it as accurate as possible – this will be your template!
Step 2: Cut out the shape with the craft knife. If you’re having trouble cutting straight lines, try using a ruler as a guide.
Step 3: Use the scissors to round off the edges of the cookie cutter.
Step 4: Your cookie cutter is now ready to use! For the best results, be sure to flour the cutter before each use.

Make With Metal
Making metal cookie cutters is a great way to add some personalization to your cookies. Not only can you make any shape that you want, but you can also make them in different sizes. This guide will show you how to make metal cookie cutters using a few simple tools and supplies.
You Will Need:
- Metal shears or tin snips
- Hammer
- Anvil or other hard surface
- Safety goggles
- -Protective gloves
Step 1: Cut the desired shape out of the metal with the metal shears or tin snips. It is best to use a template or drawing as a guide for cutting the right shape. Make sure to wear safety goggles and protective gloves while cutting the metal.
Step 2: Place the metal on a hard surface, such as an anvil. It is best to use a surface that is smooth and flat so that you can hammer the metal easily.
Step 3: Hammer the metal around the edges of the cutout shape until it is slightly curled inward. This will help to give the cookie cutter some strength and make it less likely to bend or break when used.
Step 4: Use a file or sandpaper to smooth down any rough edges on the cookie cutter. This will help to make it easier to clean and also prevent any cuts from happening when using the cookie cutter.

Looking for some fun and festive cookie cutter shapes to try? Check out these ideas:
- Heart
- Tree
- Star
- Snowflake
- Pumpkin
- Christmas tree
- Gingerbread man/woman
Tips for Using Cookie Cutters
Cookie cutters can be used for more than just cookies! Here are some tips for how to get the most out of your cookie cutter:
- Make smaller cookies by spreading the dough thinly. A thicker layer of dough will produce larger cookies, and could potentially break the cutter.
- If you’re using a complicated shape for your cookie cutter, try freezing the dough first. This will help keep the shape intact while you’re cutting.
- If you’re making a lot of cookies, consider using a template. This will help you keep the cookies all the same size and shape.
- For extra decoration, try sprinkling sugar or spices on top of the dough before you bake it. This will give your cookies a pretty, festive look.
- When you’re finished using your cookie cutter, wash it with soap and water. This will help keep it in good condition for future use.
FAQs on How To Make Cookies Cutters
Do you use cookie cutters before or after baking?
Depending on the recipe, the answer to this question will vary.
Some recipes call for the dough to be cut out before baking, while others call for the cookies to be baked and then iced or decorated.
When in doubt, it’s best to follow the recipe exactly as written. If there is no specific instruction on whether to use a cookie cutter before or after baking, then you can use your best judgement. If the cookies are going to be iced or decorated, then it’s best to cut them out after they are baked.
This will ensure that they are nice and round with sharp edges. If the cookies are going to be frosted or filled, then you can use a cookie cutter before baking. This will help keep their shape and prevent them from spreading too much.
When it comes to using cookie cutters, there are a few things to keep in mind.
First, make sure that the dough is at the correct consistency before you start cutting out cookies. If the dough is too sticky, it will be difficult to work with and the cookies will likely come out looking messy.
If the dough is too dry, it will be difficult to press into the cookie cutter and the cookies will be difficult to remove from the cutter. Another thing to keep in mind is that some cookie cutters work better than others.
If you are using a complicated or intricate cookie cutter, it may be difficult to get good results. In this case, it’s best to stick with a simple design or use a cookie cutter that is easy to work with.
What is the best way to clean cookie cutters?
Most people would think that once they are done using their cookie cutters, they can just clean it with water and it would be good as new. However, this is not the case. A soft cloth and mild dish soap are all that is needed to clean Cookie Cutters. This will remove any food residue that may be left on the cutter and will keep it in good condition for future use.
Are metal cookie cutters better or plastic?
Both metal and plastic cookie cutters have their own unique benefits. Plastic cookie cutters are less expensive than metal ones and they’re also lighter, making them easier to use. However, metal cookie cutters tend to last longer, so they’re a better option if you plan on using your cookie cutter often.
Cookie cutters can be used for what else?
Besides using them for cookies, you can also use them to make other types of food. For example, you can use them to make pancakes in fun shapes. You can also use them to make sandwiches in fun shapes.
What can I use if I don’t have a cookie cutter?
If you don’t have a cookie cutter, you can use a drinking glass or a jar. Just make sure that the edges are smooth so that your cookies will come out evenly shaped. You can also use a knife to cut them into shapes, but they won’t be as neat as if you use a cookie cutter.
How thick should cookie cutter be?
There is no one definitive answer to this question. Some factors that may influence the thickness of a cookie cutter include the type of dough being used, the size of the cookies being cut, and the personal preference of the baker.
However, in general, a thicker cookie cutter will produce larger and more pronounced cookies, while a thinner cookie cutter will produce smaller and less pronounced cookies. Bakers should experiment with different thicknesses to find what they prefer.
Would you be able to create a 3D cookie cutter?
You can make a 3D cookie cutter by using a 3D printer. However, you can also make a 3D cookie cutter by using a knife. Create the cookie cutter’s shape on paper first. Then, use a knife to cut out the shape. Finally, use the cookie cutter to cut out cookies.
Does the dishwasher work with cookie cutters?
“Yes, of course!”. Cookie cutters can be safely placed in the dishwasher. In fact, they make great dishwashers safe because they are easy to clean and come out looking like new each time. So, if you are looking for an easy way to clean your cookie cutters, put them in the dishwasher!
How do you keep a cookie cutter from rusting?
One way to keep a cookie cutter from rusting is to coat it in vegetable oil. Another way is to place it in a plastic bag and store it in the freezer. This will help to prevent moisture from getting to the metal and causing rust.

Final Thoughts
Whether you’re looking for a new and exciting way to make your holiday cookies or want to start a small business making cookie cutters, this tutorial will show you how to make cookie cutters. With just a few simple tools and supplies, you can be on your way to baking up some fun with unique cookie cutter shapes. So what are you waiting for? Get started today!
Check out other recipes at Ohsnap Cupcakes